As digital technology has advanced rapidly over the past several decades, hidden cameras have moved from the realm of spy novels and science fiction into the homes and workplaces of ordinary Americans. Many people use hidden cameras inside their homes as a security measure against intruders, while others have installed cameras near their front doors to deter package thieves.
Nanny Cams are Legal in New York
The short answer to whether nanny cams are legal in New York is yes. In fact, you can legally install and use nanny cams in all 50 states and the District of Columbia to ensure the safety of your children while you are away.
Despite the fact that this may make you want to purchase the newest nanny cam, there are still several factors to consider.
Where Can You Install a Nanny Cam?
Just because you can use a nanny cam in your home does not mean it is legal or prudent to install one in any location you choose. A number of states have enacted laws that prohibit the installation of hidden cameras in areas where individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy. Typically, this includes bathrooms or bedrooms where a live-in nanny could reside.
In 2019, a New York woman noticed an odd gleam emanating from what appeared to be an iPhone charger plugged into the wall of the bathroom where she frequently changed and showered. The “charger” was revealed to be a covert camera.
Since then, the nanny has quit her position and filed a lawsuit against the family who used the camera. If you intend to use a nanny camera, ensure that it is placed in common areas so that you cannot be accused of wrongdoing.
Can You Record Both Audio and Video?
New York is a one-party state, which means that only one party (you) must be aware of the camera in order to use it. While it is legal to use the camera without your nanny’s knowledge, you may want to consider the impact a hidden camera would have on your working relationship if your nanny discovered it.
In some states, it is legal to videotape someone without their consent, but if audio is included, both parties must be aware of the surveillance and give their consent. California, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Oregon, Pennsylvania, and Washington are among these two-party states.
What About Nursing Homes?
People frequently use (or at least desire to use) nanny cameras to monitor the safety and care of their elderly parents in nursing homes. While the state of New York does not prohibit or permit the use of hidden cameras, many nursing homes have their own regulations that prohibit the installation and use of such devices.
If you install a hidden camera in a nursing home, you may face penalties, legal action, and the inadmissibility of any evidence obtained.
What Happens if Someone Improperly Uses a Nanny Cam?
If you have been accused of improperly using a nanny cam, or if someone has improperly recorded you using one, you may wish to consult a lawyer to determine the best course of action. Although it is permissible to install a nanny camera to ensure the safety of your children, improper use could include:
- Placing a hidden camera in a space intended for privacy
- Using the footage to blackmail an individual.
- Broadcasting in public private footage that could harm someone’s reputation
The costs and benefits of using nanny cams in the home must be weighed independently by anyone who is interested. It is essential to use nanny cameras properly to avoid costly litigation and other legal repercussions in the future, despite the fact that they may help protect children in some instances.
Contact Our Personal Injury Law Firm
Contact Abrams Law Group for a free consultation if you’ve been hurt in an accident and require legal assistance.